What Happens If the At-Fault Driver Has Too Little Insurance to Cover Your Injuries?

Despite the fact that Colorado has insurance coverage requirements for all drivers, not every driver has the necessary insurance coverage in place. So, if you are the victim of an underinsured driver in Colorado, you may not know how to get the compensation you need to cover your injuries. At The Law Offices of Edward Smith LLC, our collective years of experience handling serious car accident claims across Colorado have equipped us with the experience needed to represent us in the best way possible. Keep reading to find out what your options are if you’re the victim of an underinsured driver in Colorado and how a Longmont car accident lawyer can help.

A group of legal images float above a lawyer's desk.

Insurance Coverage Requirements in Colorado

Every state tends to have its own coverage requirements for drivers, which are a legal requirement, so it’s illegal for a driver to not have at least the minimum policies in place. As of 2026, Colorado follows a 25/50/15 minimum liability coverage rule. This means that every driver needs to have at least:

  • $25,000 bodily injury per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury per accident
  • $15,000 property damage per accident

Keep in mind that although Colorado requires these minimum amounts of coverage, this doesn’t necessarily mean that they provide enough coverage for all types of accidents. Specifically for accidents involving serious injuries, these minimums may not provide the compensation you need to cover your damages alone.

When the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance Is Not Enough

Getting access to the car accident compensation you need in Colorado isn’t just a right when the other motorist is at fault; it’s a necessity. Especially if you’ve sustained injuries as a result of the accident, you most likely have excessive medical bills that you will need to cover.

The reality is that Colorado’s minimum liability limits have not kept pace with the cost of sustaining a serious injury. This is especially the case if you factor in time off work, physical therapy, or ongoing treatment needs.

The good news is that you can usually tap into some of your own insurance coverage to fill in the gaps if the at-fault driver is underinsured or even uninsured. Instead of trying to manage this on your own, you should get the help of a Colorado personal injury attorney who can help you better understand what your insurance policy covers.

How an Attorney Identifies Other Potential Sources of Compensation

If you need to file an underinsured motorist claim, one of the first steps you should take is to hire a Colorado car accident lawyer. Having legal representation is crucial in protecting your rights, navigating the claims process, and getting the best possible settlement.

The last thing you want to do is try to navigate this process on your own as you will be much more likely to miss important details. It’s also risky to try to handle communication with insurance companies on your own since this simply increases the risk of you accepting an unfair settlement offer.

Here are some of the main ways that an attorney can help, specifically if the at-fault driver is underinsured:

  • Review other insurance policies that may apply to the situation.
  • Determine whether or not uninsured/uninsured motorist coverage applies.
  • Determine if other parties hold fault.
  • Negotiate with insurance companies on a fair settlement amount.
  • Identify and collect important evidence to support your claim.

When to Pursue Formal Litigation to Recover Damages

In addition to the other potential sources of compensation that your attorney may identify, another option that you have is to file a lawsuit. However, you must keep in mind that formal litigation has quite a few drawbacks and isn’t a good solution for every accident involving an underinsured driver.

Here are some examples of when filing a lawsuit against the at-fault driver may be a viable option:

  • The driver has significant personal assets or a high income.
  • Other liable parties exist that you could sue.
  • Your damages far outweigh the driver’s policy limits or your own coverage.

On the other hand, it’s usually not worth pursuing formal litigation if the underinsured driver lacks any significant income or assets, your underinsured motorist coverage is enough to cover your damages, or the cost of litigation outweighs what you could potentially receive in return.

But if formal litigation is something you wish to pursue, you should first consult with a Colorado car accident attorney to determine if this is a realistic option.

FAQ Section

What happens if the at-fault driver’s insurance doesn’t cover all my damages?

There may be other sources of compensation available, such as uninsured/uninsured motorist coverage or additional policies.

What is underinsured motorist coverage?

It is a type of insurance coverage you can have in case you are the victim of an underinsured or uninsured driver who doesn’t have enough coverage to compensate for your losses.

Can more than one insurance policy apply to a Colorado car accident?

Yes. This depends on a case-by-case basis and will take into account the people, policies, vehicles, and circumstances involved in the accident.

How does an attorney determine how much insurance is available?

An attorney will investigate the applicable policies to determine which policies apply to the situation. Ed Smith is a former insurance attorney with nearly 30 years of experience and can also help you collect important evidence since he knows what insurance companies will look for when evaluating your claim.

Get Legal Representation From a Colorado Car Accident Attorney Today

Getting into an accident with an underinsured motorist in Colorado can feel very overwhelming, especially if you have sustained serious injuries. When this is the case, you need to get the help of a Colorado auto accident lawyer who can handle negotiation on your behalf so that you aren’t pushed around by insurance carriers. At The Law Offices of Edward Smith LLC, our personal injury lawyers in Colorado can help you get the settlement you need even if the at-fault driver is underinsured. To work with an experienced car accident attorney, contact us today at 303-682-2944 for a free consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Woman with an arm cast | personal injury lawyer colorado | The Law Offices of Edward Smith LLC
Although it can be tempting to try to handle your car accident claim on your own, this is never a good idea. A Colorado car accident attorney will have more experience with this process and can help you get a settlement that covers the extent of your injuries and damages.

Related Posts

Losing a loved one because of someone else’s negligence is a heavy burden to bear. When a family faces this situation, they often hear legal terms that sound similar but mean very different things. Two of the most common terms… Read More
Proving car accident fault in Colorado is one of the most critical parts of filing a claim and getting compensation after a Colorado accident. However, this is easier said than done since proving… Read More
The most important factor in determining the value of your car accident claim is the nature and extent of the injuries you sustained in that accident. Your medical records document the injuries and tell a story. Your attorney will use… Read More

100% Free Consultation!

Simply fill out this form and we’ll get back to you immediately.